The horrible terrorist attacks in France these last few days
has led to a lot of comment and controversy especially around the issue of free
speech/expression. I was unaware of this
magazine, Charlie Hebdo, until this incident.
But a lot of the commentary on the issue, both in India and elsewhere,
has been in my view quite misplaced. The
key issue is what, if any, are the limits of freedom of speech/expression. This touches also on another recent case, the
initial decision of Sony to stop the release of their movie, the Interview,
because of threats, reportedly from the North Korean regime. My random thoughts, set out below.
Charlie Hebdo is known for lampooning religion, religious
figures as well as political and other leaders.
A lot of commentary has focused on the obscene and offensive nature of
these cartoons and Charlie Hebdo’s particular brand of satire. Many of these cartoons
have been about Islam but many have also been about other religions, though the
primary target appears to have been French politics and politicians.
The argument in a lot of the commentary has been that while
freedom of speech/expression should be protected, Charlie Hebdo has crossed the
line (though none of the folks I saw on TV or whose columns I read suggested
that killing is an appropriate response).
The argument even among some ‘liberals’, especially but not only in
India, appear to be that free speech should also be responsible speech and that
you should not deliberately offend.
